Page 1 of 1

Flaws driving me nuts!

Posted: Sun Aug 28, 2016 9:50 am
by terryR
Thrid time in a month I have turned a stummel down to find a flaw. bummer.

How many times will this happen until i no longer care about tossing $25 worth of material? :(
image.jpg
image.jpg (98.79 KiB) Viewed 5026 times

Re: Flaws driving me nuts!

Posted: Sun Aug 28, 2016 12:08 pm
by DocAitch
Finish it and smoke it if the flaw doesn't go all the way through. You will get practice on your other techniques.
It's part of the learning experience,
I am sorry that you paid $25 for the ebauchon, but Mother Nature can be a bitch.
DocAitch

Re: Flaws driving me nuts!

Posted: Sun Aug 28, 2016 6:50 pm
by pipeguy
It will never stop hurting with briar"beauty is only skin deep but ugly cuts right to the bone" (Betty White)
Like Doc said finish it to hone skillset

Re: Flaws driving me nuts!

Posted: Mon Aug 29, 2016 9:56 am
by terryR
I was afraid the pain would always linger! :)

It's not just the $25 briar, it's the hour I spent laying out a whatever, then drilling, sanding the face of the shank, etc, etc. Then find a flaw.

I'm certain it happens all the time...just venting frustration.

Yes, I'll finish the billiard-fail for the practice....

Re: Flaws driving me nuts!

Posted: Mon Aug 29, 2016 11:36 am
by sandahlpipe
It always bugs me to find a flaw and I've been at it a few years now. When I see a flaw in the chamber, I don't finish shaping the stummel most of the time. I just reject it. At that point, I'm usually only 1/2 hour in at the most, so it's a monetary loss, but not a big loss of time. Just remember these rejects when it does come time to price your work. I'd say my average is about 1 in 10 pipes ends up a reject for flaws in the briar for me. It's gone down since I started using better briar. And I've had streaks of 5-6 pipes in a row where each one had a fatal flaw. It's all part of the game. And it weeds out the men from the boys.

Re: Flaws driving me nuts!

Posted: Mon Aug 29, 2016 3:47 pm
by W.Pastuch
You get used to it.
I used get furious to the point of throwing the stummel across the shop and destroying it with a hammer. Now I just go "meh", throw it away and take the next block.

Re: Flaws driving me nuts!

Posted: Tue Aug 30, 2016 8:26 am
by scotties22
W.Pastuch wrote:You get used to it.
I used get furious to the point of throwing the stummel across the shop and destroying it with a hammer. Now I just go "meh", throw it away and take the next block.
^^^^ This

Re: Flaws driving me nuts!

Posted: Fri Sep 02, 2016 12:44 pm
by Charl
Very true! :lol:

Re: Flaws driving me nuts!

Posted: Thu Sep 08, 2016 5:00 pm
by pipedreamer
some of my best pipes have a tiny flaw, so I keep smoking them. I have tiny flaws but keep living? Just keep carving, that day will come!!! You realize you will have to sell it??? Just isn't fair...in for a penny, in for a pound....Move on!!! :thumbsup:

Re: Flaws driving me nuts!

Posted: Fri Sep 23, 2016 6:56 pm
by Easom
I would finish it and offer it as a flawed pipe on ebay. Some find the surface flaws a nice bit of character. Offer to give a small percentage to a charity. Ebay makes it very easy to donate like that. Some one will get a nice pipe and a nice charity gets a donation and you get to buy more briar or sandpaper. Yeah
Cody

Re: Flaws driving me nuts!

Posted: Sat Sep 24, 2016 10:07 am
by pipedreamer
That is a great idea. I have been sending them to the guys overseas and a few to Marines in the states.I'm talking very minor flaws, that usually aren't that noticeable.

Re: Flaws driving me nuts!

Posted: Tue Aug 08, 2017 3:05 am
by CowboyTed
Easom wrote:I would finish it and offer it as a flawed pipe on ebay. Some find the surface flaws a nice bit of character.
I'm one of those people who find that surface flaws add a bit of pleasant character.

One of my favorite pipes has a huge gash up the front of the bowl. I didn't make it. It was an estate pipe with a rusticated finish I didn't like. I decided to experiment with my sandblaster, and see if I could make it look better. Well, I'm happy to report that it looks more than a little bit better with a sandblast finish, but In sandblasting, I exposed a huge canyon running up the front of the bowl that was apparently filled at the factory before they rusticated the pipe.

Now the pipe has a nice, uniform blast showing lovely ring grain . . . and a canyon running up the front. And oddly, I love it all the more for that flaw. It's the best-tasting pipe I have for enjoying a bowl of Balkan Saseini.

Re: Flaws driving me nuts!

Posted: Tue Aug 08, 2017 9:48 am
by oklahoma red
Like everyone says, part of the game. Mother Nature can be cruel. If the flaws aren't ridiculous try rustication. That will fix a lot of sins. Numerous posts here on how to make a rustication tool.
Like Jeremiah said, buying better briar will help but I've seen nasty flaws in the best. Watch out for some of the stuff that is on Ebay being touted as very old Greek briar. It may indeed be old but it is also Swiss cheese inside. Makes for interesting flavors in the BBQ smoker at least.
Buy from Vermont Freehand. Steve is importing from the best cutters which saves you the hassle of trying to deal direct. But again, NO guarantees! I've had Mimmo briar that went to the smoker.

Re: Flaws driving me nuts!

Posted: Sat Jan 27, 2018 2:16 am
by Bluesytone
Easom wrote:I would finish it and offer it as a flawed pipe on ebay. Some find the surface flaws a nice bit of character. Offer to give a small percentage to a charity. Ebay makes it very easy to donate like that. Some one will get a nice pipe and a nice charity gets a donation and you get to buy more briar or sandpaper. Yeah
Cody
This sounds like a great idea!

Re: Flaws driving me nuts!

Posted: Thu Feb 01, 2018 4:21 pm
by DocAitch
Do you want to be remembered as the guy who sold flawed pipe turds on eBay?
Unless you change your identity, folks will remember.
DocAitch

Re: Flaws driving me nuts!

Posted: Fri Feb 02, 2018 12:56 am
by PremalChheda
Don’t let the flaws drive you. Ignore them for now and make good shapes. Ignore the grain except when you line up the design before drilling and shaping. Plan on making every pipe a rough dark finish but after it is all shaped if it has a nice grain with minimal flaws make it smooth. I wish I would have done this early on instead of chase grain and flaws.

Re: Flaws driving me nuts!

Posted: Fri Feb 02, 2018 1:56 am
by Bluesytone
PremalChheda wrote:Don’t let the flaws drive you. Ignore them for now and make good shapes. Ignore the grain except when you line up the design before drilling and shaping. Plan on making every pipe a rough dark finish but after it is all shaped if it has a nice grain with minimal flaws make it smooth. I wish I would have done this early on instead of chase grain and flaws.
This sounds like great advice!